Zimbabwe Star
ZimbabweStar.com Friday 30th July 2010 Volume 211/2010
  • More World News

  • UN removes five former Taliban members from sanctions list
  • Hugh Hefner to give up 'adult programming' for casino chain
  • First gay marriage in Argentina
  • Mark Wahlberg receives Hollywood Walk Of Fame star
  • Won't have baby via artificial insemination, says Jennifer Aniston
  • Six soldiers, 15 civilians killed in Afghanistan
  • US recovery splutters fuelling fears of second recession
  • UAE sends aid to flood-hit areas in Pakistan
  • Over 35 killed in Russia wildfire
  • Over 400 killed in Pakistan floods
  • Plane catches fire in Pakistan
  • Pakistan uses Kashmir peace conference for anti-India tirade
    Get World News headlines emailed to you daily.

    Israelis and Palestinians once peacefully coexisted
    Zimbabwe Star
    Thursday 31st December, 2009  
    ((Op-ed) Susan Abulhawa and Ramzy Baroud)


    At one time Muslims and Jews peacefully coexisted in Palestine. Since November 29 1947 when the United Nations voted to partition the territory into separate Jewish and Arab states, that is no longer the case. Now some are calling for a return to the way things once were, a single democratic state with liberty and justice for all, regardless of religion.
    Prior to the establishment of Israel, Palestine had been multi-religious and multi-cultural.

    Christians, Muslims and Jews, Armenians, Greek Orthodox, to name a few, all had a place there; and all lived in relative harmony. Other nations fought wars and waged epic struggles to attain the kind of coexistence that was already a reality in Palestine. But while the world strives toward the noble truths that we are all created equal, Israel legislates the notion of a Chosen People with exclusive rights and privilege for Jews.

    Where countries have worked to integrate their citizens to create the richness of diversity, Israel is working in reverse, employing racist policies to "Judaize" the land whereby property and resources are confiscated from Christians and Muslims for the exclusive use of Jews. Where there is consensus that certain human rights are inalienable, Palestinians have lived subject to the whims of soldiers at checkpoints; of airplanes and helicopters raining death onto them with impunity; of curfews and restrictions and denials; and of violent armed settlers who fancy themselves disciples of God.

    Living under Israeli occupation, in refugee camps or in exile, Palestinians have endured having everything callously taken from them – their homes, their heritage, their history, their families, livelihoods, freedom, farms, olive groves, water, security, and freedom. In the 1990s, the Palestinians supported the Oslo Accords two-state solution even though it would have returned to them only 22% of their historic homeland. But Israel repeatedly squandered their generosity, confiscating more Palestinian land to increase illegal Jewish-only colonies and Jewish-only roads. What remains to the Palestinians now is less than 14% of Historic Palestine, all of it as isolated Bantustans, shrinking ghettos, walls, fences, checkpoints with surly soldiers,and the perpetual encroachment of expanding illegal Israeli colonies.

    While the Palestine Authority has led the Palestinians into a shrinking land mass, less water, more restrictions, ominous walls and merciless slaughter, notable individuals and popular movements have mobilized for Palestine as once happened for South Africa. Moral authorities like former President Jimmy Carter, Nobel Laureates Desmond Tutu and Mairead Maguire, and former UN High Commissioner for Human Rights, Mary Robinson have condemned Israeli Apartheid. Organizations supporting the Divestment and Boycott Campaign against Israel include religious institutions such as the Presbyterian Church, The World Council of Churches, United Church of Christ, Evangelical Lutheran Church, the Anglican Church, the Federation of European Jews for a Just Peace, among many others. It includes civil and professional organizations such as the National Lawyers Guild, the Irish Municipal, Public and Civil Trade Union in Ireland, as well as labor unions in Canada, Britain, and other nations. An academic boycott of Israel has spread throughout the UK and other parts of Europe and taken root in US universities across the country. The International Solidarity Movement has seen thousands of individuals go to the Occupied Territories to protect Palestinians from the violence of settlers during the olive harvest; to protect children on their daring daily journeys to school; and to bear witness to the inhumanity of military occupation. The Free Gaza movement has transported by boat hundreds of people willing to risk their lives to bring greatly needed supplies to the besieged people of Gaza.

    This Christmas, internationals will march to the Egypt/Gaza border to break this siege. These are but a few examples of growing popular support for the Palestinian struggle.

    When compared with the accomplishments of these grassroots movements, the futility of "negotiations" becomes painfully apparent. It is clear that we cannot look to our leaders (elected or imposed) to achieve justice. Just as only the masses could bring South Africa’s Apartheid to its knees, it will be the masses who will also bring Israel’s Apartheid crashing. The continued expansion of international action demanding the implementation of Palestinian basic human rights is inevitable.

    The notion of religious-ethnocentric entitlement and exclusivity for one people at the expense of another has been rejected the world over. Palestinians reject it and assert that they are human beings worthy of the same human rights accorded to the rest of humanity; that they are worthy of their homes and farms, their heritage, their churches and mosques, and their history; and that they should not be expected to negotiate with their oppressors for such basic dignities. The two-state solution was and remains an instrument to circumvent the basic human rights of Palestinians in order to accommodate Israel’s desire to be Jewish. Polls show that Palestinians refuse to be the enemies of their Jewish brothers and sisters anywhere, just as they refuse to be oppressed by them.

    It is time for the shared land to be the inclusive and diverse country it had been. It is time for leaders to follow the people’s determined movement toward a single democratic state, with liberty and justice for all, regardless of religion.

    - Susan Abulhawa is the author of Mornings in Jenin (Bloomsbury, 2010); and Ramzy Baroud is the author of My Father was a Freedom Fighter: Gaza's Untold Story (Pluto Press, 2009).

      Email this story to a friend

    Comments on this story

    By Anonymous, 12-31-09, 04:02 PM

    Palestinian writers call for single state solution

    A very superficial and misguided analysis of a complex situation. In the first place, it is patently obvious that a great many countries do NOT abide by the notion that all people are created equal. One need only look at other countries Middle East, most notably Saudi Arabia and Iran,to find countries that are dominated by the tenets of a single faith to the exclusion, and persecution, of others. One also must look at the experience of the Jewish people to see what drives Israel’s obsession with creating a
    By Didi, 12-31-09, 08:00 PM

    Lies! Lies! Lies!

    It seems that the writer targeted his words for those ignorant of the true historical facts. As an example lets look at the Title and the opening sentences:
    By Didi, 12-31-09, 08:02 PM

    Lies! Lies! Lies!

    It seems that the writer targeted his words for those ignorant of the true historical facts. As an example lets look at the Title and the opening sentences:
    By Anonymous, 12-31-09, 08:21 PM

    Big Lie

    They say if you tell a lie long enough then people will start to believe it.
    By Anonymous, 12-31-09, 08:25 PM
    This story must have been wrote by a muslim,everybody else is smart enough to know better.
    By Archangel, 12-31-09, 09:09 PM

    One state solution is correct!

    PALESTINIANS ALREADY HAVE A HOMELAND! IT’S CALLED JORDAN. MIGHTY KING ABDULLAH WELCOMES YOU! ALL PALESTINIANS SHOULD HOP IN THEIR DONKEY CARTS AND HEAD TO AMMAN NOW!!
    By Palestine, 01-01-10, 12:41 PM

    Very good and correct message

    Thank you very much for this good and accurate message. There is too much of these kazars sionists lies in TV nowadays. Thank you, may God give very soon freedom to Palestine and Palestinians (Christians, Muslims and Jews). END OF OCCUPATION
    By marge, 01-01-10, 10:25 PM

    Conflict Follows US Involvement

    Peace most likely would have continued between Muslims, Christians and Jews after the establishment of Israel if the groups had been allowed to settle their own conflicts. Instead, the US and cronies got involved in the conflicts on the side of Israel. They supplied Israel with powerful, sophisticated weapons it didn’t need. Israel used the weapons to attack and kill its arab neighbors and confiscate land to expand the borders of Israel. Now, peace is very unlikely because Israel would have to return the land it has stolen back to the Palestinians and Israel is not going to do this. Israel would rather have land than peace so the present conflict between Jews and Palestinians can go on indefinitely.
    By Anonymous, 01-05-10, 06:28 PM

    Israelis and Palestinians once peacefully coexisted

    The message in the article is right on!! Like the Jews in their homeland, they want everyone to live their faith, just like the Religious Right here in our country, including the Catholics. Keep politics and religion out of everything and people might be able to live equally!! One God, if their is such a thing, CREATED us ALL in his image, but he gave us different paths. SO what’s wrong with that? WHY do any of us have to bend to one of anything.
    By rg, 01-07-10, 10:25 PM

    read Chacour's Blood Brothers

    I have known the Palestinian story since 1965 at the Amercan University of Beirut. I always wondered why there were no personal stories telling what happened to Palestinians from WWI until the creation of the state of Israel in 1948. This is the foundation on which current events lays. Please read Chacour’s book. He is a Christian who grew up near Galilee during this period. How he can tell his story without hatred is almost a miracle in itself.

    Have your say on this story

    Your nickname (optional)
    Message title
    Message